My love for trimmed decks began when I received a trimmed copy of the Druidcraft tarot, from a friend at Aeclectic Tarot. I had owned the DC before, but could never use it due to its big cards, so I ended up trading mine away. It was a wonderful surprise to receive a well-loved and smaller copy of this beautiful deck - one I could shuffle without problems.
But it took me a while to muster the courage to grab the scissors and cut a deck myself. My first victim... I mean, experiment, was another deck I found nearly unusable due to the big cards and the extremely stiff cardstock: the Enchanted Tarot. The result was good, but there were some problems. I didn't realize the Majors and Minors were very slightly different in size, which made the final result of the trimming rather uneven (although you can only notice that if you look closely). Scissors are not the the most stable tool when it comes to cutting. I trimmed the King of Pentacles wrongly, and only managed to have a complete deck again thanks to another AT friend, who sent me a replacement of the card.
It was learning experience, but still a vexing one. I was frustrated by my less-than-perfect result, even though I still found the deck much better without its borders. But I promised myself I would not trim a deck again.
So I kept looking for decks trimmed by other people who, I had no doubt, had a greater hand coordination than I. I welcomed in my collection a beautiful copy of the Wildwood and a perfectly trimmed Hudes. And I was determined to never approach a deck with scissors again... until Sharyn, of Quirkeries, kindly sent me a corner rounder punch.
There. The trimming bug bit me again.
The most recent victim of my scissors (and corner rounder) was the Mystic Faerie tarot. When I told other card readers that I was trimming the deck's golden borders, I was surprised to get a very negative reaction. But these borders are perfect!. For others, maybe. For me, they were a constant distraction. In my defense, I can say that the shiny effect made it very difficult for me to pay attention to the card itself. And unfortunately, I happen to use the pictures in my readings, not the borders.
So bye-bye borders.
It was a very good experience. The result was much better, because I cut with more confidence. My hand was steady, and my scissors were new. I did not let the small imperfection ruin the final results, and for me the cards are much better (you can see a before & after here).
I know some people consider 'trimming' an insult to the deck. Heck, that's more or less the response I got when I posted in a tarot community that I was trimming the Mystic Faerie. Things like I'd never deface my deck like that or it feels like desecration, or even I am annoyed to see people trimming the decks I created popped up very often, much to my dismay. For me, trimming is an act of love. It's the act of turning a deck I'd not use into a deck that I am willing to read with.
To each his own. But I am not letting go of my scissors any soon...
My next victim... you'll know. Soon!


this compulsive trimmer approves of your return to the dark side :D
ReplyDeleteMystic Faerie looks awesome trimmed :]
also, in your defense, I have found after much experience that some decks are just objectively easier to trim than others. Decks with particularly thick cardstock or where lines for trimming aren't so clearly delineated (druidcraft can actually be tricky if you wanna get rid of the green inner borders because on some cards there is barely a color difference between where that ends and picture begins) can be difficult. some are tricky but you can use the backs. some are just such a pain in terms of varying card images that it may not be worth it or only limited trimming possible if you want high quality results and...yeah. my guess is that the stiff cardstock of the enchanted you describe is as much at fault for the imperfection as any ability or lack thereof on your part.
(yeah, i know way too much about the art of trimming at this point, ha)
Yes, you are right! Some decks are much easier to trim thank others. The Mystic Faerie was surprisingly simple, even though it does not have a very defined 'line' around the cards... the borders are thin, and the cardstock, not too thick.
DeleteThe Enchanted was difficult to trim... it actually left me with achy fingers, whereas the MF didn't. I guess the cardstock and big borders make all the difference. Smaller and thinner borders are far easier to trim, as long as they are not too narrow (because then it's hard to cut). So many factors!
But I definitely intend on staying in the Dark Side now, regardless of what what tarot collectors say! >:D
By the way, the trimmed Hudes you gave me is now one of my favorite decks! <3
Oh, dear! I LOVE trimmed decks… And I already have some decks shining in new splendor because they got rid of the borders. Except my TdM`s… they don´t need this procedure that is quite an initiation in my view!
ReplyDeleteIt´s especially the written word that is disturbing me. Being a child of western culture I´m used to move my eyes in a reading manner from the upper left to the lower right. And if there is a word, I have to read it again and again. That´s hindering the flow of reading images which is much more complex than reading words.
The decks I already trimmed are:
• Röhrig (Several times, because my friends just love the trimmed version. And Röhrig himself, whom I had the chance to meet, was enthralled when he saw his cards borderless. Ok, at first glance he didn´t recognize them as his own creation… But wanted to get a copy of them ;-) !)
• Thoth
• Haindl
• Cat People
You can take a look at three cards of different decks on my blog (http://tarot-wege.blogspot.com/2009/08/das-beschneiden-von-karten-oder-auch.html).
The effect in a reading is amazing. The images are no longer boxed individually by their borders but start to get connected, the sceneries emerge…
And trimming itself had a great surprise to me. When cutting off the borders of my first deck (a Röhrig), playing some classical music, it felt like a devotional. When trimming III The Empress all of a sudden I understood this energy in a way I never did before.
So, dear Marina, my congrats to your new deck!!
Trimming is a wonderful way to get to know a deck in detail, because you spend so long paying attention to each card while cutting that you can't help but SEE the deck, what it really is, its beautiful and ugly details! And like you, I think that removing the borders really free the images, allow them to become the whole card, and not just part of it! I can't wait to start working on another deck! :)
DeleteI am not working with a trimmed Hudes (gift from Tarot Bonkers!), and I am impressed by how expressive the cards are. How the images mingle without the borders, how the story seems to flow! I am amazed!
Thank you for sharing your link and the stories! It's great to know that I am not alone! :)
Ah. I never considered a trimmed MF. The borders on that one have never really bothered me. But like Phine, I have a trimmed Rohrig (my first experiment too), Haindl (borders on back and front are just a bit out, due to printing) and Thoth. I also trimmed Da Vinci and Renaissance.
ReplyDeleteI think that a bit of customisation is good. They are your cards. I think all of that stuff about desecrating cards is just silly and artists can often be too precious about their decks. If the borders have any real purpose and significance (like the Diary of a Broken Soul) then I can see a sense in them staying, but otherwise, do with them what you want. If a dress don't fit, you take it in, don't you?
I considered trimming the MF in the first moments I began to use it, because the borders really bothered me. It was really a case of 'either they go or I do', lol!
DeleteThe Haindl must look gorgeous trimmed... I have seen some trimmed Thoth, and they look so powerful and colorful!
I agree with you. I don't see why some artists get offended when people alter their decks. Do they create decks for themselves or for the readers to use? If I were an artist, I'd rather see people trimming my decks and USING them than keeping the decks new but forgotten in a drawer.
Some borders are really artistic and fit the deck. I don't think every deck needs to be trimmed, but some decks really look better without any borders. It's a matter of taste. I was just shocked to get such a negative response from the tarot community, I thought people would be more open to the idea of customizing a deck.
I love trimmed decks as well. Decks like the Haindl simply MUST be trimmed. Nobody needs grey borders. Then there are other decks that shouldn't be trimmed because their borders are so important. It's a fine line, but ultimately, you bought the deck and you can do whatever you like to it. You know I whack mine up, ink the edges, write all over them. Make the cards yours because they are. xx
ReplyDeleteCarla, I love trimmed decks too! And I agree, not every border is bad for the cards, some are an important element in the composition... and some simply FIT the card. You need to consider carefully whether to cut or not, but at the same time, we mustn't be too fearful to damaging a deck (specially if it's an easily available one). Ultimately, they are material things, meant to be used and enjoyed.
DeleteAnd trimmed if they have ugly borders, lol!